Zoey Miller is a smart college student who is more interested in computers than in romance or relationships. Everything changes when Zack, the school soccer star, gets into an accident and loses his memory, mistaking Zoey for his girlfriend. As Zoey tries to get closer to Miles, Zack's cousin and someone who shares her interests, she has to pretend to be Zack's girlfriend and spend time with his family. Caught between the two men, she begins to question her skepticism about love.